Newsflash
Home Canning Safety: Why the Type of Bottled Lemon Juice Matters
You may have noticed more brands of bottled lemon or lime juice labeled "not from concentrate" appearing on grocery store shelves. These products may be great for cooking and everyday use, but they are not the correct choice for home canning. We know many of you have questions about these newer products and about sulfite-free options, so here’s what we can and can’t recommend.
For canning, always choose bottled lemon or lime juice made from concentrate.
Why?
Acidity is one of the key factors that determines a safe canning process and helps reduce the risk of botulism, so getting it right matters.
Bottled lemon or lime juice from concentrate is required to meet a guaranteed acidity level, so you know exactly how acidic it is every time. Juice that is not from concentrate doesn't come with that same guarantee. It may be just as acidic, but there's no way to know for sure, and it can vary more from bottle to bottle depending on factors like the fruit's maturity and variety.
Since food safety in canning depends on getting the acid level right, it's best to stick with a product that has a guaranteed acidity: bottled lemon or lime juice from concentrate.
Curious why we don't recommend testing acidity at home with a pH meter instead? Read our Newsflash on home pH testing.
What about juice labeled “5% acidity”?
Some not-from-concentrate brands print an acidity percentage on the label, and others don’t. The federal standard for lemon juice sets a minimum acidity only for juice made from concentrate. For not-from-concentrate juice, an acidity claim is voluntary. It has to be truthful, but there’s no required testing schedule or FDA verification behind it, and natural juice can still vary from batch to batch. Our tested canning recipes were developed using bottled juice from concentrate. Because of that, we can’t say a not-from-concentrate juice is equivalent, even when the label lists an acidity.
What if I’m sensitive to sulfites?
Most bottled lemon juice from concentrate contains sulfites as a preservative. If you need to avoid them:
-
Tomatoes: Use citric acid instead of lemon juice. It’s sulfite-free. Vinegar can also be used, but it may change the flavor.
-
Other recipes: Use citric acid or vinegar only when the tested recipe lists them as an option. If lemon juice is part of the tested recipe, as it is in some salsas, don’t swap in a different acid.
-
Jams and jellies: Select a recipe that doesn't contain lemon juice or consider making freezer jam. In freezer jam, lemon juice helps the pectin set, but isn’t needed for safety, so fresh-squeezed or not-from-concentrate juice is fine to use. Note: Commercially produced pectin can contain a low level of sulfites. Please check with the pectin manufacturer to ask about sulfite content. For a product free of addd sulfites, choose a recipe without added pectin and without lemon juice, such as our berry jam without pectin.
-
There is at least one brand of organic bottled lemon juice available that is made from concentrate. Always double-check the label to make sure the juice is both from concentrate and sulfite-free.
Why can’t you just recommend a substitute?
Swapping one acid for another isn’t a simple one-to-one change. Acids differ in strength and in how they behave in a recipe, so any new recommendation has to be tested in the lab with the actual recipe. That kind of research takes months to years. Until then, the safest choice is to follow your tested recipe as written or choose a tested recipe that uses the acid you prefer.
The safe choice
-
Check the label: look for "from concentrate" or "reconstituted."
-
Use bottled lemon or lime juice from concentrate any time a recipe calls for it to acidify food (like tomatoes or salsa) or to help jams and jellies set (Freezer jams are the exception; see above).
-
Never substitute fresh-squeezed juice or juice "not from concentrate" in a canning recipe.
-
Not sure how much to use? Always follow the amount listed in your tested recipe. For tomatoes, see our acidification directions.
